Scam “Returns” Cashier To Prison

Defendant Erika Mitchell

Defendant Erika Mitchell

In November of 2007, Lexington police were dispatched to a clothing store on Richmond Road regarding an employee theft.  Loss prevention officials had discovered one of their cashiers, Erika Mitchell, was stealing money from the company by generating false returns.  The loss was estimated at approximately $2,000.

Prosecutor Dan Laren

Prosecutor Dan Laren

Here’s how the scam works.  The cashier collects receipts that customers discard on the way out of the store and then uses that information to create a fake return.  The cashier then processes the bogus return and keeps the money.  It looks good to the casual observer because the till balances, but security video and inventory controls will reveal that no customers or merchandise were involved and the transactions are just another form of employee theft.

Mitchell, age 36, confessed to the crime and was released from custody the same day she was arrested.  She failed to reappear in court until April of 2009.  Criminal records show that Mitchell is a felon, with 26 previous convictions for crimes including Theft, Criminal Possession of a Forged Instrument, and Bail Jumping.  She has two previous probation violations, and was on probation at the time of the offense.  Mitchell pled guilty to Theft by Unlawful Taking and Persistent Felony Offender and was sentenced to serve 10 years in the penitentiary.

You must be logged in to post a comment.